Dolphin Nautilus CC vs Dolphin Premier

Introduction

The battle between the Dolphin Nautilus CC and the Dolphin Premier represents a showdown of stark differences. When we bought and tested each, it became clear that these models cater to different needs and pool sizes. Our detailed reviews aim to guide you through their features, capabilities, and performance to help you make the right choice.

We first tested the Dolphin Nautilus CC, a budget-friendly robotic pool cleaner aimed at smaller pools. While it offers **decent pool coverage** and **basic filtration**, it’s missing several advanced features. For instance, the removal of the programmable timer and lack of NanoFilters significantly impact its efficiency and overall value. Testing it was a mixed experience, resulting in a moderate score of 6.3 out of 10.

In contrast, the Dolphin Premier stands as a high-performance option with state-of-the-art features. The Premier blew us away with its **multi-media filtration**, **waterline cleaning**, and **longer warranty**. During our tests, it excelled in every aspect, offering exceptional cleaning power and handling various pool debris types with ease. It earned an impressive score of 9.8 out of 10.

The disparity between these two models prompted us to dig deeper into their features and performance. We weighed each robot carefully, scrutinizing their pool coverage, filtration efficiency, and other functionalities to provide comprehensive insights.

To evaluate pool coverage, we observed how well each robot navigated and cleaned the pool. The Dolphin Nautilus CC covered the floor and walls but lacked waterline cleaning, while the Dolphin Premier excelled in every corner of the pool, including the waterline. Various features like the **Gyroscope** and **Smart Navigation System** made the Premier a truly hands-off cleaning solution.

We also paid special attention to filtration ability. The Nautilus CC disappointed with only a standard fine filter, making it less effective for pools with fine debris. On the other hand, the Dolphin Premier’s multi-media filtration, including NanoFilters and an oversized leaf bag, impressed us by capturing everything from fine particles to larger debris.

Our assessment extended to the features and warranty of each model. While the Dolphin Nautilus CC sadly lacked a programmable timer, the Premier not only boasted this feature but also included a media-alert full filter indicator and remote control option. The Premier’s three-year warranty further added to its appeal, making it a secure long-term investment.

For a clearer understanding of these robots’ capabilities and how they might meet your pool cleaning needs, make sure to check out our full reviews linked. You’ll find detailed information on their performance metrics, strengths, and areas where they may fall short.

In conclusion, while both models have their merits, the Dolphin Premier decidedly outshines the Dolphin Nautilus CC in almost every category. The Nautilus CC serves as a suitable option for budget-conscious owners with smaller pools, but for those seeking top-notch performance and long-term reliability, the Premier is the clear winner. Check out more of the best options on our comprehensive guide to the best pool robots.

How We Test

We comprehensively evaluated robotic pool cleaners for three months, focusing on pool coverage, filtration ability, and feature set and warranty. The Dolphin Nautilus CC received our attention due to its popularity and affordability. However, we aimed to determine if it remains a good investment for pool owners.

The pool coverage test checked how efficiently the Nautilus CC navigated a 33-foot pool, cleaning both floors and walls but not reaching the waterline. This limitation was a deal-breaker for larger pools. We had to acknowledge that while it works well for small to medium sized pools, it cannot compete with robots like the Dolphin Premier which clean up to the waterline impeccably.

In terms of filtration ability, our tests showed that the Nautilus CC’s standard fine filter fell behind other models that offer more advanced filtration options. It couldn't clear up finer debris as effectively. Units equipped with NanoFilters like the Dolphin Quantum outperformed the Nautilus CC, delivering clearer water even in tricky conditions like cloudy water levels and extensive foliage.

For feature set and warranty evaluation, we scrutinized the usability and longevity of each component. The Nautilus CC lacks the once-included programmable timer, which impacts its convenience significantly. Comparing it to other models with this vital feature reaffirms its shortcomings. Meanwhile, its two-year warranty, while standard, pales compared to robots with a three-year warranty, like the Dolphin Premier.

Overall, our three-months-long testing highlighted the need for looking at alternative options if long-term investment and advanced features are crucial. The Dolphin Cayman or Dolphin Quantum offer programmable timers and more comprehensive cleaning capabilities, outclassing the Nautilus CC in nearly all categories.

Conversely, the Dolphin Premier was subjected to similar rigorous testing, and it quickly demonstrated why it’s a top-tier option. Over the three months of testing, this advanced model showed remarkable filtration efficiency, enhanced by its variety of filters—including NanoFilters and an oversized leaf bag—making it proficient in capturing both fine and large debris. This versatility ensured a superior cleaning experience.

We meticulously evaluated its pool coverage, noting its sophisticated navigation capability and waterline cleaning performance. The Dolphin Premier does an outstanding job traversing every corner of the pool, including the oft-neglected waterline and problematic areas like stairs and drains.

Regarding feature set and warranty, the Premier boasts a three-year warranty, showcasing its durability. It includes a media-alert full filter indicator and remote control options, adding to its user-friendly nature. These features contributed to its top-notch score of 9.8 out of ten, setting it apart from other models.

In conclusion, the robust performance metrics and feature-rich design justify the investment in the Dolphin Premier. For those still considering a more budget-friendly option, we recommend the Dolphin Cayman as it bridges the gap between affordability and essential functionalities. Both robots proved themselves through extensive testing periods and delivered reliable results.

Coverage

When comparing the coverage capabilities of the Dolphin Nautilus CC and the Dolphin Premier, the differences are stark. The Dolphin Nautilus CC delivers basic pool coverage, cleaning both the floor and walls. However, it falls short when it comes to the waterline, an area it can rarely reach but not effectively clean.

In contrast, the Dolphin Premier offers **comprehensive coverage**. This robot not only cleans the floor and walls but excels at scrubbing the waterline, a crucial point many robots miss. Its advanced features, such as the **Dual Stabilizer** and **Gyroscope**, allow the Premier to navigate every part of the pool effortlessly.

For pool coverage, the Dolphin Premier earned a **perfect score of 5/5**. During our tests, it transitioned seamlessly from the pool floor to the waterline, ensuring no spot was left untouched. This thorough cleaning capability sets it apart from the Nautilus CC.

The Nautilus CC, despite being a reliable cleaner for floors and walls, earned a **lower coverage score of 3.5/5**. This score reflects its inability to handle waterline cleaning, a significant downside for pools prone to scum buildup at the waterline.

Both robots utilize navigation systems to clean efficiently; however, the Dolphin Premier’s **Smart Navigation System** provides more precise and thorough cleaning. The Premier’s navigation system reduces the chances of missed spots, ensuring optimal pool cleanliness.

It’s evident that the Dolphin Premier is superior in pool coverage. Its ability to clean from the floor to the waterline makes it a true hands-off solution. In comparison, the Dolphin Nautilus CC focuses on essential and straightforward cleaning, leaving high-maintenance areas like the waterline for manual attention.

For those requiring advanced, comprehensive coverage, the Dolphin Premier is the clear winner. If your pool needs meticulous cleaning, especially at the waterline, the Premier's features and performance are unparalleled. In contrast, the Dolphin Nautilus CC remains a good choice for smaller pools needing basic cleaning.

Ultimately, the choice depends on your pool’s needs and your cleaning expectations. The Premier’s extensive cleaning capabilities justify its higher score and make it the better investment for those seeking a top-tier pool robot.

For more insights into the best pool robots available, be sure to check our comprehensive guide. Both the Dolphin Premier and the Dolphin Nautilus CC are featured, helping you make an informed decision based on your specific needs.

Filters

When it comes to the filtration systems of the Dolphin Nautilus CC and the Dolphin Premier, the differences are substantial. The Dolphin Nautilus CC comes equipped with a standard fine filter, while the Dolphin Premier features multi-media filtration, including NanoFilters and an oversized leaf bag. This comprehensive approach significantly impacts the effectiveness and versatility of each robot.

The Dolphin Nautilus CC’s standard fine filter excels at capturing everyday debris but falls short when dealing with fine particles. It is manageable for routine cleaning but lacks the depth needed for pools with significant leaf fall or those prone to cloudiness. Our testing indicated that the Nautilus CC could not effectively clear up cloudy pool water, a notable downside for many pool owners.

In contrast, the Dolphin Premier's multi-media filtration is highly advanced. The Premier includes three different filter media options: standard filters, NanoFilters, and an oversized leaf bag. The NanoFilters stand out by capturing microscopic particles, such as dirt, sand, algae, and even oil. This option is invaluable for maintaining crystal-clear water, especially in pools surrounded by trees or other debris-prone environments.

The Premier’s oversized leaf bag adds another layer of utility, allowing it to collect larger debris that other robots might miss. This makes it particularly effective in heavily treed areas. During our tests, the Premier managed to capture everything from leaves to small twigs and bugs, demonstrating its versatility and superior cleaning power.

Comparing these two systems, the Premier’s filters offer distinct advantages. Where the Nautilus CC is limited to basic mesh filtration, the Premier provides flexibility and thoroughness, ensuring every type of debris is managed efficiently. The robust media options make the Premier a reliable option for various pool environments.

Another advantage of the Dolphin Premier is its Media-Alert feature, which notifies you when the filter needs cleaning. This ensures the robot operates at maximum efficiency without requiring constant monitoring, enhancing its user-friendly design. The Nautilus CC does not include this feature, potentially leading to less efficient operation if filters are not cleaned regularly.

Overall, these filtration systems significantly impact the robots’ effectiveness. The Dolphin Premier earns a perfect 10/10 for its filtration system, reflecting its superior capability in capturing a wide range of debris and maintaining water clarity. In contrast, the Dolphin Nautilus CC scores a 7/10, reflecting its adequate but basic filtration ability. The versatility and advanced features of the Premier make it the clear winner in the filtration category.

In conclusion, the Dolphin Premier offers a much more comprehensive filtration system compared to the Dolphin Nautilus CC. The Premier’s multi-media filtration system provides exceptional cleaning performance, making it the superior choice for those looking for thorough and versatile pool cleaning.

For an in-depth exploration of other top robotic pool cleaners and to make an informed decision based on your specific pool needs, check out our detailed guide to the best pool robots. We’ve meticulously tested and reviewed models to help you find the ideal fit for your pool.

Feature Set

When comparing the feature sets of the Dolphin Nautilus CC and the Dolphin Premier, the differences are evident. The Dolphin Nautilus CC, once a more automated unit, fell short when it removed its programmable timer. This impacts the overall convenience and usability significantly.

On the other hand, the Dolphin Premier impresses with a host of advanced features, starting with its programmable weekly timer that allows scheduling cleanings every day, every other day, or every three days. This functionality means pool owners can enjoy uninterrupted maintenance without the need for daily intervention.

One of the standout features of the Premier is its **Media-Alert** system, which notifies users when the filter needs cleaning. This ensures the robot operates at its best efficiency without requiring constant monitoring. The Nautilus CC lacks this feature entirely, placing more responsibility on pool owners for the upkeep of the unit.

Another key distinction is the availability of a **remote control** with the Dolphin Premier. This allows users to quickly and easily spot clean specific areas within the pool. The Nautilus CC, unfortunately, lacks this capability, limiting its usability for targeted clean-ups.

When it comes to warranty, the Dolphin Premier takes the lead with a robust **three-year warranty**, ensuring long-term reliability and customer support. In contrast, the Nautilus CC offers a standard **two-year warranty**, which is adequate but not as reassuring for long-term investment.

The Premier's advanced **Dual DC Motors** further enhance its performance by increasing the power efficiency and quality of cleaning. These motors allow it to handle larger pools more effectively than the Nautilus CC and help it achieve a higher flow rate of up to **4500 GPH (Gallons Per Hour)**.

In summary, the feature score comparison clearly highlights the Dolphin Premier's superior advantages. The Premier scored an impressive **4.7/5** for its feature set and warranty, showcasing a highly advanced and user-friendly design. Conversely, the Nautilus CC scored a mere **2.5/5**, reflecting its basic and now outdated capabilities.

For those seeking a more advanced robotic pool cleaner packed with useful features, the Dolphin Premier stands head and shoulders above the competition. Meanwhile, the Dolphin Nautilus CC can still cater to smaller pools but doesn't meet the demands of those requiring comprehensive and convenient pool care.

To find detailed insights and comparisons, visit our guide on the best pool robots. This will help you make an informed decision based on your specific pool requirements.

Conclusion

In wrapping up our comparison between the Dolphin Nautilus CC and the Dolphin Premier, it is evident that these two models offer very different experiences for pool owners. The Nautilus CC scores a 6.3/10, reflecting its basic cleaning abilities but missing features such as a programmable timer and NanoFilters.

On the other hand, the Dolphin Premier emerges as a far superior choice with an impressive score of 9.8/10. Its multi-media filtration system, including NanoFilters and an oversized leaf bag, robust cleaning capabilities, and long-term reliability make it a top contender. The inclusion of advanced features such as the Media-Alert system and remote control options make it incredibly user-friendly.

Considering both options, the Dolphin Premier clearly wins head to head. Its advanced features and higher performance make it well worth the investment for those looking for a dependable and efficient pool cleaning solution. The Premier is an unquestionable winner when you need the best cleaning solution for your pool.

If you find both scores unconvincing, there are better alternatives like the Dolphin Cayman, Dolphin Sigma, or Dolphin Escape. These models offer a balance of affordability, advanced features, and impeccable cleaning performance, catering to various needs and budgets. For comprehensive evaluations and more recommendations, you can check out our guide to the best pool robots.

Ultimately, both the Dolphin Nautilus CC and the Dolphin Premier offer distinct advantages. The Nautilus CC is better suited for those needing a budget-friendly option for smaller pools, while the Premier is ideal for those who prioritize advanced features and superior performance. Understanding your specific pool needs will guide you to make the right choice.

Alternate Robots

When exploring other highly-rated robotic pool cleaners, it's essential to look at models that offer comparable or superior performance to the Dolphin Nautilus CC and Dolphin Premier. Three standout options that come to mind are the Dolphin Cayman, Dolphin Proteus DX3, and Dolphin Quantum. These models offer a range of features that cater to different pool cleaning needs and budgets.

The Dolphin Cayman is an excellent choice for those who want a balance of performance and affordability. It features a **Programmable Weekly Timer**, **Hypergrip Tracks**, and the optional **NanoFilters**. With a 9.4 rating, the Cayman delivers efficient cleaning for both above-ground and smaller inground pools, making it a versatile option for various pool sizes.

Next, the Dolphin Proteus DX3 offers solid performance but comes with a few caveats. It includes a **Weekly Timer** and **Solid Vacuuming Power** but lacks NanoFilters and waterline cleaning capabilities. Despite these drawbacks, it provides reliable cleanup for smaller to mid-sized pools, although be wary of restocking fees that may apply.

For those who can invest a bit more, the Dolphin Quantum stands out with its extensive features, including **Waterline Cleaning**, **XXL MaxBin**, and **included NanoFilters**. Its exceptional performance is bolstered by dual brush technology and Powerjet 3D mobility, making it a top-tier option with a high rating of 9.7 out of 10. The Quantum truly excels in maintaining both cleanliness and water clarity.

Among these alternatives, the Dolphin Quantum shines the brightest. It bridges advanced features and robust cleaning performance, making it a formidable contender for those seeking a comprehensive pool cleaning solution. Make sure to explore our full reviews to find the perfect fit for your pool needs.